
Keynotes/Workshops
Keynotes
Friday’s Lunchtime Offerings
This lunch is on your own, though if you think you will participate in Small Group Conversations or The Writers and Readers Circle, we recommend pre-ordering an on-site boxed lunch when you register/select workshops.
Workshops [concurrent within each session]
Friday, 11am – 12:30pm
Friday, 2 – 3:30pm
Friday, 4 – 5:30pm
Keynote: The Poetry of Healing: A Doctor’s Education in Identity and Empathy Presenter: Rafael Campo, national award winning poet; faculty member and practitioner of general internal medicine at Harvard Medical School and Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center
Through a reading of poetry and prose, Dr. Campo will share his personal journey of renewal in the face of the dehumanizing biomedical training process. He will illustrate how an engagement with literary writing helps care providers to ask important questions about themselves in relation to their patients, abetting empathy while preserving professionalism. He will also explore the possibilities of healing available to both care providers and the afflicted in the narrative act.
Keynote: Listening for the Self-Telling Body: How Clinicians Can Absorb What Their Patients Emit Presenter: Rita Charon, Professor of Clinical Medicine, College of Physicians and Surgeons of Columbia University; Director of the Program in Narrative Medicine
Dr. Charon will explore how bodies tell of things—even when the person who inhabits that body might not know what the body tells. Doctors, nurses, social workers, and therapists absorb what patients tell them in words, silences, gestures, position, and material aspects of the body. In the oddest way, we are like great big radar screens taking in all bits of light and matter from an alien planet as we try to comprehend what kind of living is going on in there (and of course we understand that, to the patient, we must be like an alien planet too.) This talk will give us a chance to think together about means of improving our abilities to register and value and comprehend all that beams our way in the clinical encounter.
Keynote: The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors and the Collision of Two Cultures Presenter: Anne Fadiman, Award winning author, essayist, editor, and teacher; author of The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down
Anne Fadiman will explore the cross-cultural experience of reporting and writing The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures. Her book, winner of the National Book Critics Circle Award, traced the dramatic conflicts that arose between a refugee family from Laos and their American doctors over the care of their seriously ill child. Fadiman’s talk will trace the cross-cultural challenges she herself faced during her eight years of immersion in Hmong culture.
Art and Meaning in the World of Health Care | Session II Presenter: Susan E. Bell, Ph.D., Professor of Sociology, A. Myrick Freeman Professor of Social Sciences, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Bowdoin College, Brunswick, Maine
There is a large and growing body of material about the introduction of works of art into medicine and healing. Among other things, art can be a strategy for opening up communication between healers and patients, a means of reinterpreting events and circumstances, and an opportunity for renewal and sustenance. This workshop will address ways healers and patients have turned to works of art to make meaning and to reflect on their experiences using a variety of genres: film, photography, painting, artist books, music, poetry, short stories, and plays. Works by Jeanne Bryner, Ethan Canin, Martha Hall, Gretchen Berland, and Tomio Tada are among those that will be considered.
The Art of Facilitating: A Look at Group Dynamics | Session III Presenter: Betsy Burtis, Manager of Training and Development, Southern New Hampshire Health System
There are special issues that need to be considered when facilitating humanities-based groups for health care professionals. This workshop will give participants a basic understanding of some of these issues, focusing especially on group dynamics.
Balance & Boundaries: Personal Reflections on the Professional Life | Sessions II & III Presenters: David Loxterkamp, M.D. is a family physician in Belfast, Maine and the author of A Measure of My Days and articles for The British Medical Journal, The Journal of the American Medical Association and The New England Journal of Medicine & Hugh Silk, M.D. FAAFP, is a family physician at Hahnemann Family Health Center in Worcester, MA
Health providers employ all the usual strategies for coping with workplace stress: work harder, consume more, distance ourselves and accept frustration and mediocrity as the sad reality of our vocation. Yet that which might renew us lies immediately at hand; in fact, it is our stock in trade. Relationships—with patients, colleagues, friends, and family—are a laboratory, a park bench, a banquet feast, a mirror to our personal lives if we let them become so, and if we recognize the corners and can negotiate them. This workshop invites participants to discuss relationships and how we engage them through innovation, group gatherings, story-telling and writing. And with the understanding that all relationships are a work in progress, the “practice” of medicine.
The Caretakers’ Dilemma: Breaking the Silence | Session IV Presenter: Kathleen Sullivan, M.S.W., M.F.A., Psychotherapist and poet
This workshop addresses the dilemma of a clinician’s wanting to communicate about those moments in the healing relationship when—to quote William Carlos Williams, “just there, the thing, in all its greatest beauty, may for a moment be freed to fly...The thing, the thing, of which I am in chase,”—and at the same time respect the patient’s ownership of the story and right to privacy and confidentiality, We will explore the idea of using a poem written by the clinician and given to the patient as a means of deepening the empathetic connection and advancing, through the language of poetry, both the patient and therapist’s understanding of themselves. Additionally, these poems have the capacity to challenge the sometimes shame-inducing barrier of secrecy about what happens behind the closed doors of the therapist's office and offer the patient the opportunity to feel that telling her story might be of help to someone else.
Hopefully, the workshop will inspire other caregivers to see a poem written by them and given to their patients as a helpful gift both to their patients and to themselves.
A Clinician’s Guide to the Soul | Sessions III & IV Presenter: Veneta Masson, R.N., M.A. Washington, D.C., author of the poetry collection Rehab at the Florida Avenue Grill; her new collection of poems is titled Clinician’s Guide to the Soul
As a family nurse practitioner, I relied on countless “clinician’s guides,” concise, up-to-the-minute print or online references to specific topics like antibiotics, common skin conditions or pediatric lab values. But, a guide to the soul! What is the soul? And why, in this golden age of scientific exploration and achievement, do so many of us insist on its relevance to health and health care?
In his book, Care of the Soul, Thomas Moore writes, “Soul is not a thing, but a quality or a dimension of experiencing life and ourselves. It has to do with depth, value, relatedness, heart, and personal substance.” I would add that it is of vital importance to healers.
In this workshop, I’ll share some poems, my own and others, that have nourished me, enlarged my understanding of healing art, and guided my practice. As time allows, we’ll also exercise our creative imagination through some simple play with words and images that I think of as “balancing acts.” This kind of play is an excellent way to care for the soul and enrich our personal and professional lives.
The Courage to Write: Finding Your Voice Through Creative Writing | Session III Presenter: Judy Schaefer, R.N.C., M.A., is a part-time lecturer for Penn State. A poet, she co-edited Between the Heartbeats (1995) and Intensive Care (2003), anthologies of creative writing by nurses, and edited The Poetry of Nursing: Poems and Commentaries of Leading Nurse-Poets (2006)
Through hands-on writing and reading, this workshop will address the creative writing process for health care professionals. The barriers, frustrations, and joys of work in health care will be processed through the prism of literary devices toward a more healing, confident, and enlightened outcome for both patient and caregiver.
Exploring Grief and Loss: A Reflective Conversation with an Interdisciplinary Panel of Hospice and Palliative Care Providers | Session I Presenters: Elizabeth Hart, M.D., Family physician/hospice and palliative physician at Maine General Health in Augusta, Maine; Greg Burns, R.N., Nursing Coordinator, The JASON Program (Maine); and Kandyce Powell, R.N., M.S.N., Executive Director, Maine Hospice Council
Drawing on a few brief readings, this discussion will offer us an opportunity to consider the stories of grief and loss that healthcare professionals may carry in caring for people in times of intense suffering and at the end of life. The panel will offer insights into how healthcare professionals may grieve in ways that may impair their work or in ways that might be sustaining and therapeutic.
“Fact” vs. “Truth” in Narratives of Illness | Session II Presenter: Rafael Campo, M.D., M.F.A., national award winning poet; faculty member and practitioner of general internal medicine at Harvard Medical School and Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center
The experience of illness provides an especially notable occasion to examine a central narrative concern: the differences between “fact” and “truth.” In this workshop, we will define a “biocultural” narrative of the illness experience, in contrast to the restrictive biomedical narrative encountered in today’s health care setting. We will then consider how a better appreciation of “fact” versus “truth” may be practically useful and potentially renewing to care providers, as exemplified in poems and excerpts of creative nonfiction that join us empathetically through their sound and structure as much as through their insistent invitation to share in diverse human experiences. We will also explore the larger issue of the complex link between creative self-expression and healing. The discussion will address literary works by Thom Gunn, Marilyn Hacker, William Carlos Williams, Frank O’Hara, Veneta Masson, Abraham Verghese, and others.
Getting Intimate: Using Humanities in Medicine to Approach the Human Body | Session III Presenter: Lois LaCivita Nixon, Ph.D, M.P.H., Professor, Ethics and Humanities, College of Medicine and College of Public Health, University of South Florida, Tampa, Florida
This workshop considers challenges associated with body intimacies in professional relationships between health care professionals and patients—and ways that images and literature can help explore and illuminate sensitive issues. Participants will examine specific examples from the humanities in order to illustrate how they might be used in medical school courses and in programs for other health care professionals.
The subject of the stories embodied in the selected materials are essential components of the medical text; however, as Emily Dickinson might observe, and as participants of this workshop will explore, the humanities perspective provides a slightly different slant. We will discuss how and why the non-traditional Medical Humanities selections can generate uneasiness and discomfort among medical students and other health professionals. More importantly, we will consider the importance of such inclusions and the contributions they make to understanding and improving care.
Discussion relates to artworks by Alice Neel, Suzanne Valadon, Susan Mates, Matuschka, and Frida Kahlo; writings/poetry by Lucille Clifton, Linda Pastan, Sharon Olds, Ronna Wineberg, and Randall Jarrell; and, possibly, a filmclip. For this presentation all selected materials are related to women’s bodies on a shared journey from birth to death.
How to Show Results: Evaluative Design for Literature and Medicine Programs |
Session I Presenter: Bruce Clary, Ph.D., Evaluator, Literature & Medicine: Humanities at the Heart of Health Care; Professor and Senior Research Associate for Public Policy and Management, Muskie School of Public Service, University of Southern Maine
Humanities-based programs for health care professionals can have many positive benefits to those who participate and, in turn, for their patients, colleagues and institutions. Although these programs are generally not costly to implement, it can be difficult to make the case for incorporating them into the budgets-and ethos-of health care institutions. We will explore how the evaluator and staff involved in the national program, Literature & Medicine: Humanities at the Heart of Health Care used the Kellogg Foundation’s logic model to design an on-line evaluation for participants that measures the effect of the program in 5 key areas: empathy, job satisfaction, cultural awareness, inter-personal skills, and communication. The results have been impressive, and are beginning to make a stronger case for the value of the program.
How to Start a Literature & Medicine: Humanities at the Heart of Health Care Program at your Institution | TWO PARTS | Part 1: Session I | Part 2: Session II Presenters Include: Lizz Sinclair, Program Officer for Literature & Medicine, Maine Humanities Council and Elizabeth Motts Program Officer for the New Jersey Council for the Humanities
Learn more about this innovative, award-winning national reading and discussion program for health care professionals that, as one participant wrote, “renews the heart and soul of health care.” Literature & Medicine discussions have helped health care professionals across the country break down some of the hierarchy often experienced in health care; when the participating physicians, nurses, support staff, chaplains, administrators, allied staff, hospice workers, therapists and others who provide care sit around a table together to discuss works of literature, each has an equal voice. With the guidance of a facilitator, participants discuss readings that raise issues related to caring for people. Participants report that the program helps improves communication and interpersonal skills while increasing cultural awareness, empathy and their satisfaction with work. As one nurse who participated wrote, “The Literature & Medicine group doesn’t just support you where you are—it lifts you up to a higher place.”
Participants will not only learn about the program, its outcomes, and how to start a program, they will also get a taste of the Literature & Medicine experience by participating in a facilitated discussion of a short reading.
Looking at Diversity through the Lens of Film | Session IV Presenter: Beth Ellers, M.D., M.P.H., M.F.A., Adjunct Faculty, Film studies; Warren Wilson College, Swannanoa, North Carolina.
What do we mean by diversity? Generally, the term implies difference from ourselves. Perceived differences between us and our patients and colleagues can have an impact on our work as health care providers, causing difficulty in achieving mutual understanding, communicating effectively and/or affecting one’s comfort level. Using clips from a variety of films as examples, this workshop will explore these issues, and offer an opportunity for discussion about how to become more comfortable with situations and interactions that are stressful because of perceived differences.
Medical Readers’ Theater | Session IV Presenters: Todd L. Savitt, Ph.D., Department of Medical Humanities, East Carolina University School of Medicine; editor, Medical Readers’ Theater: A Guide and Scripts & Alyce A. Getler, Psy.D., Assistant Clinical Professor, Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School
Since 1988, the Brody School of Medicine at East Carolina University has used medical readers’ theater as a means of both educating health care students and professionals at the university about social and ethical issues in medicine and of establishing a dialog about these issues with the citizens of eastern North Carolina. The concept behind our readers’ theater program is simple: adapt short stories about medicine to a script, invite students to serve as the readers (actors), perform the stories to public and medical audiences, and hold post-performance discussions about the issues raised by the stories with the audiences and the cast. The impact of these stories and discussions is profound both on the performers and on the audience members.
The readers need not be medical students—they can be health professionals or laypeople. Anyone who can read aloud can “do” readers’ theater. The only requirements are some willing readers and a good moderator for the discussions that follow the performances. At the readers’ theater workshop we will go through a typical rehearsal and discuss how one organizes and “does” readers’ theater. A sample script will be distributed, as well as other materials useful in developing a readers’ theater program. It’s fun!
The Cambridge Health Alliance (CHA) a community healthcare system affiliated with Harvard Medical School also utilizes medical readers’ theater. The modality is used for medical/healthcare education, faculty development and interdisciplinary teambuilding. The development of the “CHA Players” an interdisciplinary “troupe” of physicians, nurses, psychologists, social workers, administrators, patient access staff and residents is an exciting outgrowth of the program. We have also studied the impact of medical readers’ theater on participants and will present initial data from a qualitative study.
Narrative Medicine Writing Workshop | Sessions II & IV Presenter: Rita Charon, M.D., Ph.D., Professor of Clinical Medicine, College of Physicians and Surgeons of Columbia University; Director of the Program in Narrative Medicine
The effective care of the sick requires deep and singular knowledge of the patient, competence and commitment of the physician, and a sturdy bond of trust between the two. Despite the many socio-cultural and professional factors that may divide doctors and patients and the impact of political and economic pressures on health care as a whole, effective medical practice needs to replace hurried and impersonal care with careful listening, empathic attention, and personal fidelity. Narrative medicine is one cost-effective and evidence-based method to equip health care professionals with the skills needed to respond to the challenge. By fortifying clinical practice with the ability to recognize, absorb, interpret, and be moved by stories of illness, narrative training enables practitioners to comprehend patients’ experiences and to understand what they themselves undergo as clinicians. Professionalism, cultural competence, bioethical competence, interpersonal communication skills, self-reflective practice, and ability to work with health care teams can be strengthened by increasing narrative competence.
This workshop will offer an overview of the narrative medicine process and will involve writing and reflection.
Spiritual Grounding for Health Care Professionals | Session I Presenter: Marguerite Stapleton, Vice-President for Mission Effectiveness at Sisters of Charity Health System in Lewiston, Maine
How do healthcare professionals ground themselves spiritually in their work lives? What would appropriate practices in spiritual grounding look like in a healthcare setting? If we want to initiate practices in spiritual grounding at work, where do we begin? Are there differences in spiritual practices and religious practices? This session will give participants the opportunity to examine these questions through shared wisdom, practical implementations, and best practices through both discussion and presenter input.
Two Successful Approaches to Incorporating the Humanities in the Education of Health Care Professionals | Session II Presenters Include: Marjorie Boyd, M.D. & Ann Lemire, M.D., of the Maine Medical Center Residency Program and Martin Kohn, Ph.D., co-founder, Center for Literature, Medicine and Biomedical Humanities, Hiram College and Joseph Zarconi, VP, Medical Education and Research, Summa Health System, Akron, Ohio
We will present two successful approaches to integrating the humanities into the education and training of health care professionals. For each, presenters will share background about the program, how it is structured and how it has been beneficial to their students amidst the stresses of their education and training. There will be time for discussion and questions, including time to share other approaches that workshop participants have taken.
1. The Medical Book Club: Maine Medical Center’s Experience with Internal Medicine Attendings and Residents
This session will give an overview of a book club that has been in existence for 18 years at Maine Medical Center. It evolved from with varying interests of the different Internal Medicine residents who have voluntarily participated since the inception of the book club. We will give an overview of the books chosen for discussion, the themes of some of the discussions and the setting where the book club took place.
2. Re-Imagining the Lives of Patients / Discovering How to Care for Them and Ourselves
Martin Kohn will discuss the narrative bioethics sessions that he has offered for 3rd year Northeastern Ohio Universities College of Medicine (NEOUCOM) students as part of their internal medicine clerkship experience.
The “mini-course” offered consists of a one-hour orientation followed by three 2-hour story-based discussion sessions. Prior to the orientation session students read a story, “The Death of Bed Number 12,” by Ghassan Kanafani. This work serves as a cautionary tale for the students who have been instructed to come to their first discussion session with a story they’ve written in the imagined interior monologue voice of a patient for whom they have provided care. Using the student written stories as a springboard for discussion of the morally turbulent waters of patient care, we have also discovered that our discussions also often lead to issues of care for caregivers.
This workshop will be participatory, and will, as time permits, aim at simulating the experience of our students.
What’s a Nice Discipline Like Literature Doing in a Medical School? | Session I Presenter: Kathryn Montgomery, Ph.D., Professor of Medical Humanities & Bioethics, Professor of Medicine, and Director of the Medical Humanities & Bioethics Program, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois
After a short account of literature and medicine in medical education, participants will read and discuss a few of the short stories and poems that have been often included in the medical curriculum. Texts by doctors, nurses, and patients include William Carlos Williams’s “The Use of Force,” John Stone’s “Talking to the Family,” Jeanne LeVasseur’s “Hospital Parking Garage,” and Sharon Olds’s “The Pact.”
Friday Lunch Offerings
Small Group Conversations: You will receive a group number so that you may participate in a randomly pre-assigned conversational group. [Also offered during Saturday breakfast.] No pre-registration necessary.
The Writers and Readers Circle: Victoria Longino from the Medical Humanities Interest Group of Massachusetts College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences will moderate this informal gathering where attendees can read aloud and talk about their own healthcare-related writing—short or long, incubating or completed. Victoria and her colleagues will also share their own work. [May be offered at additional times if desired.] No pre-registration necessary.